Pennsylvania

Inequities in Graduation Rates

Black and White male students in Pennsylvania graduated at higher rates in 2005/6 than the national average.[1] The racial achievement gap is close to the national average.

The Benchmark for graduation rates of Black male students for states enrolling more than 10,000 Black male students is 74% (New Jersey).

Male Students

Graduation Rate 2005/6 (est.)

Graduation Rate 2004/5

Black
Males

Black

White

Gap

Black

White

Black Change

White Change

USA

4.3mil.

47%

75%

28%

47%

74%

0%

1%

Pennsylvania

150,161

58%

84%

26%

56%

81%

2%

4%

National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) Evidence of Inequities

NAEP Grade 4 Reading results for Pennsylvania are slightly above the national average for White, non-Hispanic males and slightly below average for Black male students. Well over half of the state’s Black male students read below the Basic level at Grade 4.

Percentages Of White and Black Non-Hispanic Male Students At Each Achievement Level, Reading, Grade 4, 2007

Race

Jurisdictions

Below Basic

At Basic

At Proficient

At Advanced

White

USA

26

36

29

9

Pennsylvania

22

33

31

13

Black

USA

59

30

10

1

Pennsylvania

61

29

9

1

At Grade 8 nearly half of the state’s Black male students read at less than the Basic level and virtually none reach the Advanced level.

Percentages Of White and Black Non-Hispanic Male Students At Each Achievement Level, Reading, Grade 8, 2007

Race

Jurisdictions

Below Basic

At Basic

At Proficient

At Advanced

White

USA

22

46

30

2

Pennsylvania

18

45

34

3

Black

USA

53

39

8

#

Pennsylvania

46

44

10

#

More than one-third of Pennsylvania’s Black male students score below the Basic level in Grade 4 Mathematics, four times as many as the state’s White, non-Hispanic male students.

Percentages Of White and Black Non-Hispanic Male Students At Each Achievement Level, Mathematics, Grade 4, 2007

Race

Jurisdictions

Below Basic

At Basic

At Proficient

At Advanced

White

USA

9

38

44

9

Pennsylvania

10

32

47

11

Black

USA

38

47

14

1

Pennsylvania

39

44

16

1

By Grade 8, half of Pennsylvania’s Black male students score below the Basic level in Grade 8 Mathematics and one percent reach the Advanced level.

Percentages Of White and Black Non-Hispanic Male Students At Each Achievement Level, Mathematics, Grade 8, 2007

Race

Jurisdictions

Below Basic

At Basic

At Proficient

At Advanced

White

USA

18

39

33

10

Pennsylvania

14

38

36

11

Black

USA

54

35

10

1

Pennsylvania

50

33

16

1

The Benchmark for Black male students in Grade 8 Reading is Massachusetts, with 62% of Black male students scoring at or above Basic.

The Benchmark for Grade 8 Mathematics is Texas, with 63% of Black male students scoring at or above Basic.

Discipline, Special Education, and Advanced Placement Inequities


The number of out-of-school suspensions given to Black male students in Pennsylvania was five times that awarded to White male students in Pennsylvania in the 2004/5 school year, as reported to the Office of Civil Rights of the U. S. Department of Education. In proportion to enrollment, six times as many Black male students were expelled as were White male students.

Black male students were admitted to district Gifted and/or Talented programs at less than half of the rate of White male students, while more than twice as many were classified as Mentally Retarded. Many more Black male children were classified by the State of Pennsylvania as Mentally Retarded as Gifted/Talented. If Black male children had been admitted to Pennsylvania’s Gifted and/or Talented programs t the same rate as White male children, at least 3,000 more would have been in those programs.

Given their respective shares in the student population, more than six times as many White male students were allowed to take Advanced Placement Mathematics and Advanced Placement Science classes as Black male students.

Footnotes:
1. This is the first year that Pennsylvania has reported data to the National Center for Education Statistics. Graduation rate estimates are, therefore, less reliable for Pennsylvania than for other states.